COBRA vs Marketplace: After a Job Loss banner with a briefcase, health shield and calendar

COBRA vs Marketplace: Health Insurance After a Job Loss

Losing a job usually means losing your health insurance too. You normally have two main choices: keep your old employer plan through COBRA, or switch to a plan on the ACA Marketplace. COBRA keeps everything the same but is often expensive. A Marketplace plan can be much cheaper, especially if your income has dropped, but you may need to change doctors or plans.

The deadlines matter as much as the price, so start here.

The deadlines you must not miss

OptionYour deadline
Elect COBRAAt least 60 days from the later of your election notice or the date your coverage ends
Enroll in a Marketplace plan60 days before to 60 days after your job-based coverage ends (a Special Enrollment Period)
Medicaid or CHIPAny time of year

You can sign up for a Marketplace plan up to 60 days before your work coverage ends, so the new plan starts right away with no gap.

How COBRA works

COBRA is a federal law that lets you keep your employer’s group health plan after leaving a job, usually for up to 18 months after a job loss or reduced hours. Some events, such as divorce or a death in the family, can allow up to 36 months for family members.

  • Same plan, same doctors, same deductible progress. Anything you have already paid toward this year’s deductible still counts.
  • You pay the full premium, including the share your employer used to pay, plus up to a 2% administration fee. That is why COBRA often feels expensive.
  • No subsidies. Marketplace tax credits do not apply to COBRA.
  • Coverage can be retroactive. If you elect within the 60-day window and pay, COBRA covers you back to the day your work coverage ended.

COBRA generally applies to employers with 20 or more employees. Many states have “mini-COBRA” laws for smaller employers.

How the Marketplace works after a job loss

Losing job-based coverage qualifies you for a Special Enrollment Period. You can choose any Marketplace plan available where you live and may qualify for:

  • Premium tax credits based on your expected income for the year
  • Cost-sharing reductions on silver plans if your income is low enough
  • Medicaid, if your income has fallen far enough

Subsidies are smaller than they were from 2021 to 2025. Our guide to Open Enrollment 2027 explains what changed.

COBRA vs Marketplace side by side

COBRAMarketplace plan
CostFull premium plus up to 2%Varies; may be reduced by tax credits
Doctors and networkUnchangedDepends on the plan you choose
Deductible progressCarries overStarts again from zero
How longUsually up to 18 monthsRenew each year
Best forOngoing treatment, met deductible, short gap before a new jobLower income, no ongoing treatment, longer gap

When COBRA usually makes sense

  • You are mid-treatment or pregnant and want to keep the same doctors.
  • You have already met most of your deductible this year.
  • You expect a new job with benefits soon and want to avoid switching plans twice.
  • Your income is too high for Marketplace tax credits.

When the Marketplace usually makes sense

  • Your income has dropped and you qualify for tax credits.
  • You are healthy and do not mind a new network.
  • You need coverage for longer than a few months.

The trap: dropping COBRA later

Be careful if you start on COBRA and later want to switch. Voluntarily dropping COBRA, or stopping payments, does not give you a new Special Enrollment Period. After your 60-day job-loss window closes, you generally have to wait until Open Enrollment or until your COBRA runs out. When COBRA ends on schedule, that does count as a loss of coverage and opens a new 60-day window.

A simple way to decide

  1. Get your COBRA premium from your election notice.
  2. Get Marketplace prices on HealthCare.gov using a realistic estimate of this year’s income.
  3. Compare total cost: 12 months of premiums plus each plan’s out-of-pocket maximum. See how to choose a health insurance plan for this method.
  4. Check your doctors and prescriptions on any new plan.
  5. Decide within the 60-day windows.

Frequently asked questions

How long do I have to sign up for COBRA?

At least 60 days from the later of your election notice or the date your coverage ends.

Can I switch from COBRA to the Marketplace?

Yes, during your original 60-day job-loss window, during Open Enrollment, or when your COBRA ends on schedule. Not by simply cancelling COBRA partway through.

Is COBRA always more expensive?

Often, but not always. If you do not qualify for tax credits, a Marketplace plan with a similar network may cost about the same or more.

Does COBRA cover my family?

Yes. Spouses and dependents who were on your plan can usually continue too.

Sources

General information only. Check your COBRA notice and HealthCare.gov for your exact deadlines.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *