Car Insurance After an Accident: How Much Rates Rise banner

How Much Does Car Insurance Go Up After an Accident or Ticket?

An at-fault accident is one of the biggest things that can raise your car insurance price. Recent rate studies put the average increase after one at-fault accident at roughly 35% to 60%, with most estimates in the 45% to 50% range. The real number for you depends on your insurer, your state, the size of the claim and your record.

What the studies show

Several comparison sites publish their own analyses of insurer rates. They use different methods, so the numbers differ, but they point the same way:

SourceAverage increase after one at-fault accident
NerdWallet (April 2026 analysis, full coverage)About 48%; individual insurers ranged from about 26% to 61%
LendingTree (at-fault claim of $2,000 or more)About 45%
MoneyGeek (property damage of $1,000 to $1,999)About 49%
InsurifyAbout 34%

The spread between insurers is the most useful finding. The same accident can raise one company’s price by about a quarter and another’s by more than half. That is why shopping around after an accident can save so much.

Why insurers raise your rate

Insurers price on the chance you will file another claim. Their data shows that drivers with a recent at-fault accident are more likely to have another one. Most insurers apply a surcharge for a set period, commonly three to five years, and it often shrinks each year that you stay claim-free.

What affects the size of the increase

  • Who was at fault. At-fault accidents usually raise rates. Not-at-fault accidents often do not, though some insurers still adjust.
  • The size of the claim. Accidents with injuries or large payouts tend to bring bigger surcharges.
  • Your state. Some states limit when and how much insurers can surcharge.
  • Your history. A second accident or a ticket on top of the first can push your rate much higher.
  • Accident forgiveness. If you have it, your first accident may not raise your rate at all.

Tickets and violations

Tickets raise rates too, though usually by less than an at-fault accident for a minor speeding ticket. Serious violations such as reckless driving or DUI bring much larger increases, and a DUI can lead some insurers to cancel or refuse to renew.

What you can do after an accident

  1. Report the accident to your insurer. Your policy almost certainly requires it, and failing to report can cause bigger problems than a surcharge.
  2. Ask whether you have accident forgiveness. Some insurers include it after several claim-free years; others sell it as an add-on.
  3. Think about small claims. If damage to your own car is minor and no one else is involved, paying yourself may cost less than the surcharge over three to five years. Never skip reporting an accident that involves another driver or injuries.
  4. Shop around at renewal. Because surcharges vary so much, get quotes from at least three insurers. Our guide to comparing auto insurance quotes shows how to compare like for like.
  5. Take a defensive driving course. In some states it earns a discount or can offset a point on your record.
  6. Raise your deductible if you can afford it, to bring the premium down.
  7. Check every discount you qualify for. See our list of car insurance discounts.

How long an accident affects your rate

Most insurers look back three to five years when setting your price, and accidents are also recorded in claims databases for longer. Once the accident drops out of your insurer’s lookback period, your rate should come down, assuming no new incidents. Our guide to how car insurance premiums are calculated explains the other factors in your price.

Frequently asked questions

Does insurance go up if the accident was not my fault?

Usually not much, and often not at all, but it depends on the insurer and state.

How much does one at-fault accident raise insurance?

Studies put the average at roughly 35% to 60%, with most around 45% to 50%. Your own increase depends on your insurer and situation.

Can I avoid a rate increase by not filing a claim?

For minor damage to your own car only, sometimes. You should still report any accident involving another driver, injuries or property damage.

What is accident forgiveness?

A feature that stops your first at-fault accident from raising your premium. Rules for who qualifies vary by insurer.

Sources

General information only. Rates and rules vary by insurer and state.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *